Thursday, 19 March 2015

No, ISIS isn't the new Khmer Rouge

This is something I wrote a few weeks ago, but wasn't picked up by any media/journals, so rather than let it go to waste, here it is. There have subsequently been a few articles published which further try to link the two regimes together, but as I think I have show here, they are really rather different.

No, ISIS is not the new Khmer Rouge

There is a common theme running across many articles about ISIS – a need to reference the Khmer Rouge. In some cases this is little more than a name-drop or to briefly mention how the two groups are different. In others the comparison is the centre of the whole piece, with the authors normally focusing on two keys areas:  both groups’ love of gruesome executions and the parallels in the US’s unintentional involvement facilitating their creation. While these links can indeed be made, it is also relatively simple to find a point of comparison between any two entities - dinosaurs and sheep are both animals but few would seriously compare the two. In the case of the Khmer Rouge and ISIS comparisons, it doesn’t take long to find more aspects highlighting their differences rather than their similarities, and yet such comparisons continue to be made.

The most repeated similarity related to the brutality of the executions by the Khmer Rouge and ISIS. There is no disputing the crude and savage methods employed by both groups to kill large numbers of people, however even in this area, the differences are clear.

ISIS' recent public execution of the Jordanian pilot, Muath al-Kaseasbehis, is steeped in symbolism and is a clear escalation of their violent imagery.  Footage of crucifixions, beheadings and at least one homosexual man thrown off a building are designed to rally the troops and to stoke fear in the enemy. These made-for-TV executions, justified with selective reading of religious texts and historical events are intended for the world to see and indeed fear. After bursting onto the 24-hour news cycle last year, their burning quest for increased media coverage has driven and shaped their slick and polished online presence, recently aided in this by Fox. A lauded social media machine ensures that the executions, often by beheading, spotlight an ever-increasing desire to be taken seriously and be feared.

Access to technology notwithstanding, the executions committed under the Khmer Rouge were not for public dissemination. Instead, Pol Pot sought to project an image of a peaceful Cambodia. The barbarity of the regime was actively hidden from the world, with no Western journalists allowed to visit until late 1978, and the killings were expressly kept from their domestic population; going so far as to play music to mask the sounds of interrogations and mass executions. The Khmer Rouge certainly killed many people, often brutally, as recent testimony at the ongoing UN assisted Extraordinary Chambers in the Courts of Cambodia (ECCC) demonstrates: Children smashed against trees, and throats slit with garden hoes. By the end of 1979 it is estimated that almost a quarter of Cambodia’s population (2 million people) died, either as a result of war, starvation, exhaustion, illness or execution. S-21 security centre boss Duch was sentenced to life imprisonment by the ECCC for overseeing the execution of over 17,000 detainees, many of whom in the later stages were themselves Khmer Rouge cadres.  They did indeed execute people, often by brutal means, but the use of farming tools was more to do with the extreme material limitations faced in Cambodia than a conscious effort to make a statement.

It is clear that both ISIS and the Khmer Rouge are synonymous with the frequent and gruesome killing of prisoners, with the latter’s practice only being widely known and believed after their removal from power. However, one can find such a similarity between almost any violent groups, many whose actions are more recent than the Khmer Rouge. If brutality is the only qualifying criterion, then why no mention made of Rwanda, Liberia, Sierra Leone, Yugoslavia or Chechnya?

Executions and brutality aside, the other point of reference for those attempting to draw similarities between the Khmer Rouge and ISIS is America’s perceived role in the group’s creations.

Lead by a handful of French, Thai and Vietnamese educated communist intellectuals and headed by Pol Pot, the Khmer Rouge came to prominence only after Nixon authorised the dropping of more bombs on Cambodia than were dropped on Japan during WW2,  in the process ensuring the deaths of up to 500,000 people. This support for the disastrous campaign in neighbouring Vietnam, and to prop up Cambodia’s American supported government of Lon Nol, who had taken power in a coup in 1970. The anger felt by Cambodians towards the Americans boosted support and recruitment for the Khmer Rouge, who had long and rather insignificantly been fighting against the government forces. Despite receiving initial training and support from the Vietnamese Communist Party, after taking power in 1975 the Khmer Rouge leadership increasingly allied themselves with China.

ISIS, so the comparison goes, is also a creation of US bombing. The American led second Iraq war saw the toppling and execution of Saddam Hussain, and the much heralded arrival of 'Democracy.'  The US-created power vacuum in Iraq, which lifted Saddam's boot of oppression, saw Sunni and Shia militias fight for political control, and the removal of American troops, and this is what has allowed ISIS to grow as it has. In the coalition-run prisons set up after the invasion, various Sunni individuals, members of the numerous militias and factions, were kept together with little more to do than talk and share ideas. They became senior leaders in the Sunni militias, and eventually formed ISIS. The regional chaos and influx of fighters and arms to the civil war in neighbouring Syria provided the perfect launching pad for ISIS to emerge. Funded and supplied in part by supporters in friendly Sunni Gulf States, their rapid spread from Syria through much of western Iraq, ethnically cleansing the Shia communities, and  minority Christian, Kurdish and other groups in their path, has presented a terrifying prospect for Western governments.

At this point the comparison has been taken to its extreme conclusion. Any further look at the groups simply serves to prove how dissimilar they are in almost every aspect.

Unlike ISIS, the Khmer Rouge was not looking to recruit international members to its cause, or to spark similar global revolutions.  Executions simply sought to remove anyone associated with the previous government (or accused of being CIA or KGB spies) and to ethnically cleanse the country of its non-Khmer population, most notably the Muslim Cham minority and the Vietnamese. News of a family member’s death, rather than being widely broadcast for propaganda purposes, was often only confirmed years later when the security center records became available, and remnants of families reunited.

Further differences in the comparison are easy to find. Control over Cambodia’s existing borders was the primary goal of the Khmer Rouge, who were unwilling, and most probably unable to export their extreme brand of Communism. There were incursions into southern Vietnam, a region traditionally and ethnically linked with Cambodia, but this action was not the spearhead of a concerted effort to spread their message. It served instead to antagonise Vietnam, which eventually invaded and removed the Khmer Rouge from power.

ISIS, on the other hand, has set its sights on expansion from the very beginning. It is obviously too early to talk of their demise, but their reign thus far has been very different compared to the Khmer Rouge. Indeed, for specific areas there are there closer comparisons available. The speed with which ISIS has swept through vast swathes of the Levant, killing many in their wake, draws comparisons with the Mongol horde’s 13th Century achievements in the region.. But with the goal of creating a Sharia Law-enforcing Sunni caliphate, this blitzkrieg, to use a more modern comparison, has not been accompanied with the complete destruction of the existing state, in an anti-intellectual and anti-industrial fervour ala the Khmer Rouge. Securing dams and oil wells shows an economic and strategic pragmatism, and their media presence certainly cannot be called anti-technological. ISIS has aimed to demonstrate that it has total control in the region. It has redrawn borders to reflect the desired religious make-up, and ethnically cleansed those groups that are not compatible with this vision. It has sought to project sovereignty over this region by providing all trappings of statehood and exerting the monopoly of force required, even if recent events suggest they are failing in this regard.

With the ISIS/ Khmer Rouge comparison crumbling under scrutiny, an explanation is needed as to why journalists and reporters attempt to compare this new dangerous force with earlier ones. Such a need to compare new with old is certainly not confined to this context, with music albums or TV Series – seemingly just about everything these days - requiring a comparison with a better known and established entity. Neither are such comparisons a new phenomenon. Churchill compared the Nazis to the Mongols, and indeed Hitler praised Nazi “quickness” and “brutality” in relation to Genghis Khan. ISIS currently represents the West’s boogie man; it is bound to draw comparisons with similar entities that have come before it.  Although why a regime that ruled Democratic Kampuchea - as the Khmer Rouge renamed Cambodia -  for almost four years in the late 1970’s has been chosen for this role is unclear.

As President Obama recently discovered when comparing ISIS and American views on Islam with the Christian crusades, choosing examples that dare to question the inherent “goodness” of your own side is fraught with difficulties. Choosing to compare one widely hated group with another similar group is much easier, especially when knowledge about them is minimal.

A non-ISIS comparison to the Khmer Rouge certainly isn’t difficult to make.  The use of nationwide prison camps, prison labour, arrests based on little more than the desperate pain-ending denouncements of the tortured, the mass movements of people and the lengths taken to keep the brutality secret, may accurately be describing Stalin’s gulag system, or present-day North Korea, rather than anything ISIS has sought to achieve. Conversely, Boko Haram’s use of shocking violence and kidnapping, intended to both repulse and recruit, is a much better comparison to ISIS, even before taking into account the similarity of their religious message and their Al-Qaeda links.

It is clear that both groups certainly owe some of their initial success to the actions of the US. The idea that anger against American actions leads to recruitment, as well as a destabilising effect on regional authority and rule of law is not disputed. However as a unique and central point of comparison between the two, this argument is weak. The Nazis and Japanese both blamed American actions for provoking them in the 1930s, yet these claims haven't been included to support the ISIS Khmer Rouge comparison. Neither case involved direct American military action, but with the strict German armistice conditions following WW2, and trade embargoes on Japan following its invasion of China, US involvement cannot be denied.  

Is ISIS a cruel, brutal group, dangerous not only to the inhabitants of the Middle East and the stability of the region, but also to larger values of democracy and secularism? Indeed. Was the Khmer Rouge also cruel and brutal? Yes, but the danger they represented was reserved almost exclusively to the population of Cambodia, and was not antagonistic to the rest of the world, and it is upon this clear division that the comparison again breaks down.

It is easy to project our ideas of what ISIS is, onto what we have determined were the overall aims of historic regimes. At the same time sometimes forgetting that these were often evolving ideologies, subject to internal and external factors not entirely planned, and in some cases driven by the whims of (questionably sane) leaders.   

To claim that a new terrible group is merely a resurgent or copy-cat form of an earlier one, is an overly simplistic characterisation, attempting to force the opinion that history repeats itself. Such lazy attempts at analysis are too dangerous to be allowed to be repeated. It has the effect of elevating the importance of the new group - and in this modern era, this means media coverage - while at the same time lessening the impact of what we know of the former groups.  

So is ISIS the new Khmer Rouge?  While it is true that both Khmer Rouge and ISIS were strengthened in the craters of US bombs, have a barbarity at their core and  a deeply driving ideology, the answer is no. However they are certainly an unwanted addition to the long list – which humanity seems bent on extending ad infinitum - of cruel and barbaric groups and regimes whose blind belief in the superiority of their message, whether divinely supported or not, places them at odds with the rest of civilisation.
Humouring this flawed comparison for hopefully the final time, one of the main factors in the Khmer Rouge’s demise - assisted by antagonistic military incursion against a more powerful neighbour - was its paranoia fuelled cannibalistic purging of the senior command. Is it too much to hope that ISIS will succumb to a similar fate?

No comments:

Post a Comment