Monday, 27 October 2014

Week 4 - Bag theft

“Those who believe that evil can be eradicated tend to identify themselves with the good and attack anyone they believe stands in the way of its triumph.” From the article i mention later

 
On Thursday evening, after spending a very enjoyable (and sweaty) two hours playing street hockey with a nice group of expats and Cambodians, I was cycling to see a friend when my bag was stolen. While I was cycling. A moto with 2 Cambodian males drove past, barely pausing as they wrenched my shoulder bag off me, and zoomed off. I gave chase, mainly from an overwhelming feeling of helplessness and anger than from any rational belief that I would catch them. I had never before been robbed, despite visiting many post-conflict/continuing-conflict and developing nations (as well as London), and I had developed a cosy bubble around me to explain this – I am tall, male and athletic, and nice to people, and therefore nothing bad will happen to me. Within two seconds, this idea has been crushed forever. I am not invincible, and all the best preparation in the world is irrelevant when something can happen so quickly. Thankfully I am unhurt, although I found it impossible to sleep, coming up with all sorts of ways I could have reacted differently. A (gift) phone with a cracked screen, a wallet with $5, now cancelled bank cards, my driving license, a spare camera battery, my umbrella, and my chopsticks from Japan; the bastards have hardly gotten away with a bag of loot. Still, does put a bit of a damper on Cambodia, which is a shame, as I really rather like the place.

It was rather pertinent then, that I came across this article the following day, “The Truth About Evil” in The Guardian. While its focus is heavily Nazi/Stalin based, largely ignoring Rwandan and Khmer Rouge ‘evil’, it is a very interesting look at different beliefs and theology surrounding the concept of evil, and the role this plays in current geopolitics and world affairs. It also helped me get some mental closure over the robbery.

“Many liberals would like to see the idea of evil replaced by a discourse of harm: we should talk instead about how people do damage to each other and themselves”
Indeed, I do not believe in the idea of evil as a counterbalance to God or good, and find the idea of original sin just ridiculous. The men who robbed me are not evil, they just believe that their needs justify the means required to satisfy them - making money without working. This doesn’t mean I have to like them, or support their actions, but it does remove some of my anger. Their action wasn’t a personal attack – any westerner with a bag is a victim. 

On the flipside, it has meant that I have needed to buy some replacements. Given the number of ethical shops here, with either staff/producers or a % of sales aiding the disabled, abused or recovering of Cambodia, this has been less of a chore that it could have been. I now have a silk wallet ($5), and a good idea for small gifts for people when it comes time to leave. Alas, I wasn’t abled to find any chopsticks. While Japan is full of shops selling bespoke, beautiful chopsticks for home and eat-out use, it seems Cambodian’s are perfectly happy to use disposable ones. So while I saw lots of hand-carved wooden bowls and spoons, I had no luck with chopsticks, and will have to order a pair from neighbouring Thailand. 
 
On Friday morning, on the bus ride to court, we passed a huge group of protesting garment workers. Plenty of banners and smiles from the young ladies lent the whole thing a very friendly feel, which given their suffering, and the attitude of the factory owners is really surprising. They all waved and cheered when they saw a bus of foreigners go past – I have a horrible feeling this was because they thought we were representatives from Nike or Gap or whoevers stuff they make. 

This Vice documentary gives a good overview of the current complaints, and the issues surrounding NGO intervention. Sometimes what we perceive to be the worse option - in this case sex work - may well not be. 

Pertinent to this, are my thoughts on Aeon Mall, the brand new Japanese mega-mall in Phnom Penh. It is full of shops selling the usual big brands, at Western prices ($100 for a pair of running shoes). This just seems criminal when you consider the fact that many of the clothes and shoes were made in Cambodia itself, by someone paid $2 a day. Not only can you find the exact same products at the local market – factory overruns, or 2nds – for a tiny fraction of the asking price, but a huge percentage of the nation cannot afford to pay the Aeon prices.

The whole mall seems to cater for the expat and Cambodian upper-middle/upper classes, who are so cut off from the realities of life in Cambodia for most people, that $50 for a t-shirt, possibly made in Cambodia, but just as likely to have been imported from Bangladesh, or Pakistan, or somewhere else where the people who made it were paid almost nothing, is not something they find strange. Even at the budget end, there was a weeked flash sale on cheap plain t-shirts, for $5 reduced to $3. These had come from Bangladesh, with tags in Japanese, and it is entirely possible that they were first shipped there, before being shipped to Cambodia. For $2 you can find an equally cheap tshirt at the market, which was made in Cambodia. The carbon-footprint, not to mention the sheer ridiculousness of it all just boggles the mind.

Friday, 24 October 2014

Week 3 - Kep

My work has been rather simple at the court so far, as there haven’t actually been any hearings taking place. This was all set to change this week, with Friday seeing the first session of case 002/02, with two of the top Khmer Rouge facing charges of genocide, crimes against humanity and war crimes. The day didn’t start well, with a group of civil parties – victims of the Khmer Rouge who have agreed to testify or take part in the trials – complaining that the 11 reparations agreed by the first trial – including building a memorial, producing books, having PSTD workshops and community projects – were not what they wanted, and that they only pleased NGOs. Instead, they are demanding $13,500 each. The projects would benefit the wider Cambodian population, and benefit from lots of research into treating and helping post-conflict societies, while cash payments rarely work for anything outside the immediate family . It is frustrating to see money dominating something that should be so positive, especially as such demands are so unlikely to be met.

 (Good morning - the rainy season is still in full force)

The next bit of excitement was the whole Defense team walking out of the court in the afternoon, citing an inability to prepare for the appeal to case 002/01 and this current one (despite the fact the prosecution has to do the same), and that since they have applied to have all the judges removed anyway, case 002/02 shouldn’t have even started. So it is currently unclear when, if ever, the next case will actually start. Oh the joys of working in an international court!

 (White sand)

This past weekend I went to Kep, a small sea-side town and the former resort area for Phnom Penh’s rich. With that social group being largely exterminated by the Khmer Rouge, and with the regime’s anti-money policy, their opulent villas were ransacked and abandoned. Today, this means concrete shells surrounded by jungle, providing rather poignant reminders of the ravages of the war. I tried to visit one of the biggest, once a royal retreat, on a hill overlooking the beach. However a family seemed to be squatting in the ruins (a common occurrence, we saw a policeman living in another one), and their dogs were very aggressive. What was odd was that the topiary still seemed to be being done on the large ornamental trees in the garden, despite the main house having no roof! So I retreated past the pack of wild monkeys, back to the beach and tourists and my group. A stripe of white sand about 100m across, pretty clean, and gently lapped by bath warm water is the main draw of Kep, and it was very relaxing. No loud music, no hawkers, and no begging kids instantly set this beach apart from ones I have visited in the past 6 months, and it was really rather nice.

 (Topiary elephant)

(Checking his hair)

We went for a walk around the local national park, a forested hill jutting down almost to the water. While we didn’t see any animals, the easy loop path took us away from all of the noises and pollution of Phnom Penh, and it was a very peaceful 2 hours.

 (Temple and the plains)

Other than the beach, Kep is most famous for its crab, especially when cooked with the famous fresh pepper from neighbouring Kampot (where I was 2 weeks ago). Sitting in a simple wooden hut (next to 20 other identical but competing huts) jutting out over the water, with un-obstructed views of the sea and distant islands, it is a fantastic experience, and $6.50 for crab isn’t bad either!

 (Crab and pepper by the sea)

On the way back to Phnom Penh, we stopped off at a pepper farm to pick up some fresh sprigs (and to see how the stuff is grown – it turns out I win an argument while I was studying in Colorado (yes, it was almost 10 years ago, but I remember these things) and yes, as I insisted, pepper grows on vines, and not trees – but I digress. It was fun to see the stuff that we take for granted being grown, and managed to get a big bag of fresh ones to cook with. Prawns, pepper and tofu coming up for dinner tonight!

 (Pepper growing)

We also managed to visit another cave complex, near the town of Kampong Trach. Unlike last time, where we had the place to ourselves, as an active pilgrimage destination this one was rather busier, although with Cambodians rather than tourists, which somewhat excuses the noise and chaos….somewhat. Walking through a low subterranean tunnel, it suddenly opens up into what can only be described as the middle of the mountain! The roof of the cave must have fallen in many millennia ago, creating a natural tree lined amphitheater that was really rather impressive. Surrounded by Buddhist shrines and statues, including a few damaged by the iconoclastic Khmer Rouge, it was most certainly worth the $1 entrance fee. 

 (Inside the mountain)

 (Both sides)

 (The heads from destroyed statues)

Another great weekend with friends in the countryside.

Monday, 20 October 2014

Week 2 - Getting the feel of the city

"In the end, it was enemies created by the regime itself - foreign and domestic, armed and unarmed, political operatives and sullen survivors - people alienated by the regime's attempt to destroy perceived enemies, who brought about its downfall."

Reading Ben Kiernan's The Pol Pot Regime, as much due to its interesting subject matter, as for a better understanding of the people being tried by the court. Despite having a background knowledge of the Khmer Rouge, and the regions politics post WW2, I very much need to know more, and this is a great (big) book for that.

As a way of making a bit of extra money on the side, as, let’s face it, unpaid interns don’t earn very much, I have secured a 5hour a week English teaching job, after work twice a week. Working in a language school very similar to what I was doing in Japan was certainly not on my list of things to do here, but $60 a week in cash will go a long way to covering my living costs (rent is $150 a month + food). My only student will be a Japanese dentist, and hey, how hard can he be! 

 (Grilled bananas, really rather nice)
Taking a tuk-tuk (motorbike with a trailer on the back) home from the school, I passed the Anti-Corruption Headquarters, and was thinking what a hard job they must have here, when I spotted across the road a Rolls-Royce car dealership.  In a country where the GDP = $2,600 per person a year, $200,000 cars are clearly not within the reach of the average person. With Cambodia being ranked 160/177 in terms of the most corrupt states, the Anti-Corruption office clearly has its work cut out. Stories of illegal logging, land rights, people smuggling and just plain old racketeering abound, and the number of shiny cars and huge villas I have seen would seem to attest to this.
Such rampant capitalism is hard to ignore, and it makes it even harder to believe that for a few years in the 1970’s, the country was in the grips of a brutal communist dictatorship. The Khmer Rouge walked into Phnom Penh in 1975, after fighting a largely rural civil-war against the corrupt, Western supported government. Fighting against all of the usual things revolutionists tend to – corruption, nepotism, entrenched political class, foreigners, taxes etc. – they initially found the sympathetic population supportive. It is only upon visiting S-21, the prison/torture chamber set up in Phnom Penh to house their enemies, that one sees how whatever worthy and important causes led to the Khmer Rouge’s creation, by 1975, it was morally rotten to the core.

 (The school buildings)
The school buildings which form S-21 are, remarkably, similar to the school I taught at in Kazakhstan, following a very similar format – stairs at either end, lots of concrete, and an educational environment about a million miles away from the one I was lucky enough to enjoy in Britain. What I mean by this is that trying to imagine the horrors (of which there were many) that were perpetrated in the school before the Vietnamese liberated Phnom Penh in 1979. Sitting in grassy, spacious and remarkably peaceful grounds for the city, with school exercise equipment still providing further evidence of the benign role the buildings were intended for. And it is the buildings that are the focal point of the whole museum, with little in the way of exhibits, information or gloss, but rather open access to the rooms and corridors where the horror happened. Photos of the prisoners have been enlarged and fill walls of space, a gory nod to the Nazi-like efficiency of the bureaucracy employed in torturing and condemning to death 20,000 people. Their faces hint at the suffering, and add a human side that the bleak rooms otherwise lack. Many of the victims, in the later years of the Khmer Rouge, were Khmer Rouge themselves, sacrificed in an orgy of infighting and paranoia, rather like Stalin’s purges.   

 (Gym bars)
 (Keeping people in)

 (Classrooms divided into smaller cells)
 (3 different facial expressions, all in pain)

 (The classrooms)

 (Rooms of photos of victims)
It is certainly worth a visit, the $3 entrance fee certainly not being a hindrance, and it has been useful to try and place myself within the realities of the Khmer Rouge period, as sitting in my air-conditioned office an hour outside of town, surrounded by foreign interns, it can be hard to imagine how things must have been.
On a lighter note, I now have a bicycle – racing red – which will hopefully survive the next 5 months. A re-cycled (up-cycled?) Japanese shopping bike, it is rather creaky, but hey, it has a basket and only cost $34. I also have a rice cooker, which cost rather more, but means I’ll wake up to freshly cooked rice, or having it waiting for me after work, and I can make soup/porridge/steam vegetables etc, all rather conveniently. 

And that pretty much sums up week 2 in Cambodia- Consumerism, Corruption and Communism. 

Went to watch Cambodian Kick-boxing last weekend. Not out of any burning desire to see men fight each other, but rather for the experience of watching a classical sporting event in the country of its origin. Watching Sumo in Japan was more about the rules and rituals than two morbidly obese men slap at each other, and it was much the same with kick-boxing. Live traditional music from a group of children, a rowdy group of locals getting very much into the spirit of things (financially as well as vocally), cheap and tacky sponsorship moments, and no entry fee!  

 (The winner)


Saturday, 11 October 2014

Arrival in Cambodia, and weekend trip to Kampot

Well, another week, another country. I will be in Phnom Penh in Cambodia for the next 5 months, interning at the ECCC - the UN supported court set up to hear cases relating to the Khmer Rouge leadership.

 (My local Buddhist Temple)


I am working in the Public Relations department, monitoring media coverage of the court, document and media creation, social media, and assisting in the outreach programmes which see people from the provinces bussed into the court to witness what is being done in their names. It is this attempt to really involve the populations most affected by the violence committed against them, that sets this court apart from previous ones, which have operated (or seemed to) behind closed doors.

(A quiet spot in the country)

I look forward to all the things i will see and help with over the next 5 months.

Arriving, pretty much directly from West Africa (3 days in England doesn't really count), the shock of Phnom Penh is great. It is amazing that a city in a developing country (living costs here seem similar to that of Dakar or Freetown), can be so clean, orderly and pleasant! Yes, the traffic is pretty manic, and there is lots of construction going on, but it really is very far from the cities I have left behind. It is a really nice place to live! It is difficult to explain really, but it has a positive energy and drive that is fun to be around. Everyone is moving quickly, with a purpose, and there is fantastic street food on every corner.

 (Lush farmland- Thanks rainy season!)

Only 5 days here, and i had already escaped the city for a weekend with 13 other interns, at the coastal town of Kampot. Famous for its pepper (corns, not chilli) it was a lovely relaxing experience, with our guesthouse facing onto a river, and forested hills. The food was fantastic, with plenty of fresh (green, and much milder than when dried) pepper in everything.

Visited a 7th century shrine hidden in a cave, which was amazing to see. The cave protected it from the weather, and presumably the Khmer Rouge.



Driving back into Phnom Penh, in the pouring rain the endless clothing factories that line the highway - H&M, M&S, Gap, Nike...the brand list is rather long.